If you've inherited a stack of Bradford Exchange plates—or worse, a whole collection wall—you're probably wondering: are these worth anything? The short answer is usually no, but let's dig into the details so you can decide whether to eBay them, keep them, or use them as frisbees.
The Short Answer: No, They're Not Retirement Gold
Bradford Exchange plates were marketed as limited-edition collectibles that would appreciate in value. They didn't. Most plates sell on eBay for $5 to $20, often as a lot. For example, a Thomas Kinkade “Christmas Morning” plate (a popular one) sold recently for $12.50. A Precious Moments “God Bless This House” plate? $9.99. The Mickey Mouse 60th Anniversary plate—once $40+ retail—fetched $15. And that's before fees and shipping.
Even the fancy ones with gold trim and a COA rarely break $30 unless it's a rare theme or a complete set. I once saw a Hummel “Apple Time” plate go for $22. That’s about the price of a decent pizza. So yeah, your collection is not funding a vacation home.
But Wait – Are Any Valuable?
Yes, but only a few. These exceptions usually involve:
- Complete sets (e.g., a 12-plate Norman Rockwell series) that sold as a lot for $80–$150.
- Limited editions with low mintage (under 3,000) and in mint condition. A Danbury Mint “Song of the Lark” plate might hit $50.
- Christmas plates from the 1970s or 80s that still have the original box and paperwork. One 1973 Bing & Grøndahl Christmas plate sold for $75, but note: that’s not a Bradford Exchange plate—it’s a different brand. Bradford Exchange ones rarely hit that.
Tip: search eBay for “sold items” using the exact name of your plate. If you see multiple sales under $20, you have your answer.
Shipping: This Is Where They Get You
Bradford Exchange plates are heavy, fragile, and oddly shaped. Shipping one plate costs around $12–$18 via USPS or UPS once you add bubble wrap, a sturdy box, and insurance. Selling a $15 plate? You’ll net maybe $2 after fees and shipping. Sell a lot of 5–10 plates together and you’ll only pay one shipping cost—that’s your best bet.
Also: if the plate arrives chipped, eBay will side with the buyer, so pack like you’re shipping a Fabergé egg. Tape the bubble wrap, don’t just throw it in a box.
What Should You Do With Them?
Here’s the practical, no-bull recommendation:
- Donate them to a thrift store, nursing home, or church rummage sale. Someone will pay $2 for the nostalgia and you’ll get a tax deduction.
- Sell them as a lot on Facebook Marketplace for $20–$40. No shipping, no fees. A local collector might take them off your hands.
- Keep the sentimental ones. If Grandma specifically gave you the “Bunny in a Bonnet” plate, hang it in the laundry room. It’s a nice memory, just not a payday.
- Repurpose them as coasters, wall art, or bird feeders. (The internet loves a DIY project, and it’s more honest than pretending they’re antiques.)
Bottom line: Bradford Exchange plates aren’t worthless—they have emotional value. But if you’re hoping to cash in, lower your expectations. Use them as decorations, give them away, or accept that the only thing appreciating here is the dust on top.